How do you tag bands - the?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

dunlopj

Mac Daddy DJ
Aug 14, 2008
6,443
8,191
67
Belair MD
I'm in the process of switching all my artist tags and file names from last name first to first name first - yes coming over to the dark side.

Thankfully, thanks to RockIt's multi-tag editor and Tag & Rename, it hasn't been that hard - just time consuming.

How do you tag bands such as The Beatles? Do you title them just "Beatles", or do you use "The Beatles"?

If I use "The", them I'm gonna have a whole bunch of artists starting with "The". And that seems a little weird to me.

I've got "Band", "Flamingos", "Drifters" etc and that sounds OK to me.

Your thoughts?

Yea I know - Why didn't you do this from day one? I dunno, maybe the anal-retentive in me got in the way.
 
I have always stripped "The" from band titles. That makes searching easier...so I do not have 500 artists in the "T"'s.

Some programs can be set to ignore some common keywords when doing alphabetical sorts. That can be handy.

Media Monkey is great at making changes like this. You can even keep the "Album Artist" with the "The" and the "Artist" can have the "The" stripped.
 
For me, it depends on what my mind thinks... :)


For example, I always think of The Beatles, The Band, etc., so that's how I tag them. Some bands are just Eagles, Rolling Stones...

Searching shouldn't matter, as typing "beat" will return results from either The Beatles or Beatles, The, etc.

Some people are anal about it, and insist on everything being exact, but I sometimes wonder if that's not overdoing it a bit, since I believe you should work with what your mind is used to...
 
Quote:

Some people are anal about it, and insist on everything being exact, but I sometimes wonder if that's not overdoing it a bit, since I believe you should work with what your mind is used to...


Gee Rick, you pegged me exactly!

But at least your multi tag editor is helping me be exact. Is RockIt being an enabler??
 
All the poo in one pile and very linear (straight).

There's a reason librarians and researchers adhere to certain rules. People expect it and it make it easier to find things.

Put articles “the”, “a”, “an” at the end of the title or track.
Numbers are spelled out so they sort properly. For example, Ninety_Two_Degrees.
Group names listed as written except as above.
Individuals listed as last name first, first name second, middle name last.

If the library is small it isn't as important. If the list is only for your use, most especially inside the player software the computer can still find what you're looking for anyway. If the ID3 is to be used to create a hard copy song list or artist list, putting articles at the end and listing last names first is the only way to go. This is most especially if the hard copy list is to be used by your customers.

Additionally, I add the program source to the end of each file. For example, tracks bought from Amazon end in _AZ.MP3. Tracks from my vinyl are listed as _V3.MP3 or _V3.WAV if it was from an LP. Forty Fives would be listed as V4.MP3, a track from a cassette (not many of those) _CS.MP3.


Anal yes but I like to have my SH** together.
 
Anal yes but I like to have my SH** together.

The above has been noted, and added to your permanent record Sir. :D


If at some point, you would like to dispute this, you may contact us below:

Bag, Dirt (The)
Road, 123, Avenue
11111, myTown, NY, ASU


:sqlaugh: :rofl:
 
In my "manually" entered database, I dropped all the "The(s)" :sqwink: Always have and always will... :sqwink:
 
Beatles, The
Use commas.

Also, last name first.
Dylan, Bob

Saves time rather than looking through a zillion Bobs'.
If you tag ALL your files properly, it makes a world of difference later. Tag it non-consistant or half-azzed, you'll have problems later.
 
Bill, so I see you prefer the method I used - last name first.

The main reason I want to go to first name first is because all the music you d/l is on that format. I change it, but my Zune software in most cases chooses to revert back to first name first.

Plus my daughter's I Tunes software also sometimes changes the artist tags.

So I decided to stop fighting and go with the majority.

But I do agree with your thinking.
 
I have my physical media sorted by last name, first name because I always did it that way. However, I have my tags set as first name last name because that's how they are typically tagged and it doesn't matter to me because searching finds it anyway. When browsing I am typically sorted by song name, genre or possibly year, but rarely by artist name.

Scott
 
Another related question:

When a track has two artists (i.e. Endless Love with Mariah Carey and Luther Vandross), what/how do you tag it?

Most d/l's has the secondary artist listed in the song title.
 
I go with the comma philosophy too...Beatles, The

With names I USED to go with Buffett, Jimmy but whatever importing software or places I was buying downloads from all go the other way - Jimmy Buffett so I just said "to hell with it" and gave in...

As far as the multiple artists on one song, I always use the "&" sign....Mariah Carey & Luther Vandross. On all the hip hop songs that have "featuring" I ALWAYS use "ft." Whatever you use on those, make it the same for every single one or your library will be messed up.

And then when you have more than one artist on the hip hop songs, I will use the "&" sign or "," or both depending on how many other artists there are...

i.e. Flo Rida ft. Eminem & Dr. Dre. OR Flo Rida ft. Eminem, Dr. Dre and Homer Simpson.
 
I just let it come in the way it is from the data base. I don't change it. Like rick mentioned, I don't really care if it's listed as the beatles, beatles, or beatles, the.

when I search for beatles, it all comes up anyway.

when I'm browsing genres, it's just hits in there, so there won't be tons and tons of songs to flip through.
 
Here's what I used on a per track basis:

The follows in all cases except where it makes no sense (The The)
Beatles, The

Artist names are in normal written order (not 'reversed')
FirstName LastName

Band names are just 'band name'
LMFAO

Artists that are numbers, use numbers where it makes sense.
2 Pac
2 Unlimited
38 Special

For multi-artists tracks:
Artists=Artist Name
Track Name=Track Name (Feat. 2nd Artist Name)
Artist Name generally comes from the 'main' artist on the track or album.

I use Media Monkey to manipulate most of the tags en masse so it's less of a problem. As I find new tracks that fail to follow these rules I change them to match.


But I should add, this works for ME. You need to do what works for YOU.
 
In my "manually" entered database, I dropped all the "The(s)" :sqwink: Always have and always will... :sqwink:

There is Medication for that you know! :sqlaugh:
 
I typically drop "the" off of band's names unless it's an integral part of the name. Mostly because when you look at the database....there are pages and pages of "the ???" bands.
As for naming multi artists? I would label them "Mariah Carey-Luther VanDross.
I do not list any tag with Beatles, the or Dylan, Bob.
When someone comes up and asks for a request, I want to type it as it is requested.
Like Elvis Presley. As I type Elvis....I get Presley...Crespo and so on until I narrow it down.
This is what I have been doing for over 10 years and I'm happy with it.
 
Mine are tagged just as the artists is listed, with year of the disc and bit rate (if available) beside it:

music1.jpg


music2.jpg