I can't speak for Joe, but for me personally its because ALL MP3 PLAYERS SOUND LIKE CRAP.
Furthermore, its impossible to beat mix using I-Pods (no speed control).
My daughter has owned an I-pod for over a year, and I've had quite a bit of time to play around with hers.....she usually leaves it plugged into my computer (where she loads her I-Tunes) while she's in school.
I've done "A-B" comparisons between the I-pod sound, VS. the original Compact Disc sound. NO CONTEST!!!
Don't get me wrong......MP3's recorded at the 311 kb/sec or higher sound pretty decent. Unfortunately, my daughter (like most teenagers) wants QUANTITY of songs, not quality.
Played in the car stereo, using one of those tape adapters, the I-pod sound even worse than cassettes. And don't get us started on those "Radio Frequency" adapters......we returned ours at Best Buy (and ended up with the fake cassette doo-dad) because the sound was very distorted!
Compact Discs are still my media of choice. Yes they are cumbersome and heavy to carry but they still have superior sound quality.
You cannot remove 90% of the data from a file, without creating serious degradation of the signal quality. Hence the poor fidelity of 128-160 MP3's.
Nuff Said....
Some new cars are equipped with a headphone jack input installed on the dashboard. This allows you to buy a cable that has a 1/8" plug on each end. One end in the ipod, the other end into the cars dash hooked to the radio. There is no longer a need for a cassette adapter or fm transmitter, both of which I have not had a problem with.
I know Toyota offers this feature, not sure who else.