Certification by Peers? I think NOT!

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
After reading what The Lady who wrote the book on DJing has posted in another sister forum, i must admit that I am very disatisfied with her proposal.

DJ Goddess Lady:
Why? It seems like if you go to a seminar that you are automatically grafted in as a certified professional. Certified on what standards? Buisness, Ethical, Leadership, Cost, Interaction, Music Knowledge, etc. I think having any type of certification would be biased depending on the president of the organization, or the person doing a review... Is it true you have certain biases about members on the forum... Think a moment... I certainly do. Members here may have a bias about me. They are either good or bad biases, and upon that a certification may be issued, in fact think of the repercutions if a DJ is given a negative certification... The rants and raves on a web board would be disasterous!

Johnny's Model:
The reason I like Johnny's model is purely on the "Certified by the People" which basically means to me, if your doing sucessful in your buisness and market, and attempting to accept the code of ethics, you must be good or at least doing something right. Let your knowledge speak for how qualified as a DJ you are. And if you are unqualified learn from the boards to become to your "peoples" qualified or certified. It all has to do with working hard, learning, providing the best entertainment possible.

Conclusion:
I believe a DJ's learning never completely stops, so certification isn't necessarily a good idea. Idea's, technology constantly adapt, and so must the DJ. Even the idea of biases come into play. Where do you set the bar? You cannot, I bet there are some industry "leaders" who are put to shame by nameless members of the industry who never even visit a forum, or belong to an organization. So just because the leaders speak up and not the silent one, does that make the industry "leaders" idea correct? I do not think so. In ending, please consider NO to certification by peers. It would create a whole new set of headaches, not to mention hurt feelings in the industry. Any thought's comments? Revisions... Amendments?
 
The certification dilemma is equivalent to the alleged DJ Hall of Fame BS.

While I’m sure there are 1 or 2 quality members of the HOF, the qualification(s) for induction are as shallow as a tea cup saucer.

The "Who get's to decide who decides?" and "What qualifies them at all?" questions are necessarily asked by concerned individuals.

For all the talk about certification and unification, there are many more "industries" that prosper and survive without any such standards or guidelines and do so to the benefit of the best of the lot.

I certainly would have a problem,:tank:, with some self-appointed, unelected individuals assuming the throne and deciding on the fate of my business status.
 
LOL!

I am getting to the point that I feel my fingers are getting trained to type this next response out of repetitious habit.

There are only two uniform common factors present at any event a mobile DJ is performing:
1) The human element.
2) The music.

At some point, it will sink in that there is no way possible to define, corral, encompass, certify, legitimize, label, or otherwise classify the human element.

If we needed a legitimacy (which proactively, I strongly feel we need only for a defensive posture) the music is the only factor that is addressable.

Next, who will approve the governing body? There are too many questions and uncertainties there, also. People won't see any clout in a set of criteria that are too lax. Whereas having standards set too restricively are just as counter-productive.

It boils down to Certifications are nothing more than a means of additional marketing.

I am Certified.
It says so on my business card and my nametag.

I doubt that beyond a subliminal assurance level, certification in my case means very little to peers, and maybe something to a consumer. Therefore certs are for marketing only.
 
After reading what The Lady who wrote the book on DJing has posted in another sister forum, i must admit that I am very disatisfied with her proposal.



Shouldn't a person who is considered a DJ "Godess" at least have a real website for her business and not some AOL hosted site? Is this someone that should be considered a "leader" in our industry?

13 year old kid DJ's have real websites. Why can't a DJ "leader" who has sold countless books. You would think SHE could afford a real website.
 
You cannot certify any art or artist, period. That brings us to another question are DJs artists or just business men with an affinity for music? I'm going to go with we're artist stance because I believe that to be the case. :)

Certification of DJs is an endless circle. We have no set of requirements to be a DJ heck you could own a few CDs, two boom-boxes and call yourself a DJ.

As Ken points out who certifies the certifiers? Who's qualified to certify whom?

In my opinion it's an endless circle and we'll never reach nationally recognized certification because as Wolfie says "We're all wildcaters at heart" there is a lot of truth to that statement.

-Dan

PS: Ken, I like the nametag ;)
 
Completely Subjective?

OK guys. Never mind what they call it but it is going around in a circle.

The wisdom of certification aside, are all you guys saying that you cannot think of objective criteria for certification? Are you all saying there are no clearly objective skills to be mastered and measured? No technical understanding that might be tested? No knowledge of musical history? Is all that a DJ does wholly subjective?

What say you all?
 
Is all that a DJ does wholly subjective?


Yes.


Gigs are different in all parts of the country. Country music is the most popular genre in America. You know how many country songs I play at a gig? ZERO. Maybe 1.

Do you really think schools in NYC are dancing to Toby Keith? Nope.

It's not just music. Weddings here go

Intros
First Dance
Speeches/Toast
Meal
Open Dancing
Cake Cutting
Parent Dances
Garter/Bouquet
Dessert
Open Dancing
Finale


That is NOT the norm across the country.

Audio equipment? What line do you draw on whether something is pro grade? Sure, we can agree that JBL, Mackie and other are considered pro. What about Gemini? Is that pro? to some yes, to others no.

If you say Gemini ISN'T pro gear that what if I have an entire Mackie rig but my mic is Gemini? Does that mean my gear isn't pro?

What about interactivity? Some guys are low key, some high energy. Can they BOTH be pro?

Who's going to watch over DJ's to make sure they stay certified?

If there ever is a DJ certification it will be lead by some group that accepts anyone as long as they pay a fee or something.
 
First of all old boy, I made one stricture. Let us not or at least I will not argue about the wisdom, the propriety, or the value of certification. Not all in one go at least.

For the time being, let us answer one question: Is everything a DJ does the role of an artist? Is everything a DJ does subjective? Basic, you answered yes it is all subjective.

Whether schools dance to Toby Keith or not is irrelevant. The question might be asked this way: You are playing music for a young urban group, the last song you played was Sexyback the feedback from the selection was positive. Toby Keith was suggested for your next track. Would you play a selection from this artist? Why or why not? Or the question might be how would you tactfully explain to the customer his selection might not be appropriate.

Regardless of what area of the country you reside there are certain norms of behavior. Emily Post is still published Miss Manners is still read. There is protocol. Etiquette still exists. Is this learned or infused by artistry? Is etiquette too the realm of the artist?

Once more, is beat mixing different in different parts of the country? Would a little knowledge about AC power or how your computer works vary in different parts of the country? With more and more Djs going computer it might be handy to have some understanding here too. Do computers work differently in your neck of the woods?

If your gear ceases to function and it is now your role to troubleshoot and resolve the problem are you still an artist? Will the problem be resolved by subjective means?

Once again, keep the debate to the point. Certification of gear is a whole ‘nother kettle of fish. Up to now we’ve been talking about certifying the DJ. Let’s keep it there for now.

You prove to me that there are NO objective criteria on which a certification might be based.
 
This was posted by cesar on another board...


Is this what you really want?

Year 2010 - Venue - Hilton or Radison or Marriot or any other venue your familiar with.

Bride or Client books the venue and receives her packet of information from the venue. Tucked away in the menus, rules and policies is a DJ information sheet. First line states that all DJs working at this venue must be current members in good standing with the local ADJA Chapter. This local and regional ADJA Chapter dues are 500 dollars a year and and this local chapter has taken a vote with the majority of members voting that the appropriate dress for events such as a Wedding Reception should be Tux or Tux vest with gold monogramed ADJA lettering.

Caterer manager is a proud member of N.A.C.E. and has instituted this policy after networking with the local ADJA chapter.

Is this really what the Mobile DJ is hoping for when thinking how to better the Mobile DJ Industry.

The reason why I express my views is that I belive that all this talk about certification and organization is to someday eliminate the independent DJ. I am an Independent DJ that answers to only himself and I like it that way. I do not like the future as seen through the eyes of some of these so called DJs that express their opinions and expect no opposing voice to be heard.

I'm not posting this to debate my views with certain Kool Aid drinkers. I just wanted to express my feelings and to vent a little.

The only question I really would like to know from the DJ Chat readers is how many of you have Booking Agents?

Cesar
 
Melodrama

It seems more that a tad melodramatic to me. What would the incentive be to hotel chains to exclude the guest’s vendor of choice? Is the author opposed to formal wear?
 
Exactly

Why is Jay citing a post that proposes an outcome that is very unlikely to occur? Along with ruining perfectly good tux with ADJA lettering?
 
Gentlemn,

What cesar predicts is not as far fetched as you might suspect.

There is a hotel in my city that has one service elevator that only two of their employees, both union elevator operators, are authorized to operate. If neither is on site, vendors requiring access to the upper floor facilities have to wait until one of the two authorized operators arrives and is paid triple time to push the buttons and close the gate.

If a national DJ association became powerful enough, read rich enough, to grease the right palms, nothing is out of the realm of possibilities.
 
Sir, if unions hi-jacking access to elevators all across this fair country is our greatest fear, the state of the nation is secure.

I'll believe a cabal between all the national hoteliers and the ADJA is possible right about the time I also believe the Roswell, New Mexico story is also true.
 
Folks,

The ADJA isn't gonna do any more than they've ever done because they're too disorganized. Merry's image of the ADJA directors holding a "board meeting" in a hot tub being passed around the Internet was telling enough. Shirl and I have met and chatted with some of the founding fathers of the ADJA. They can share some hair-raising experiences, believe me...

Little has changed, believe me. :)

DJ associations will always be a challenge to coordinate. When your president lives in one state, your membership director lives in another and your secretary and treasurer live in yet others, a meaningful industry lobby isn't going to materialize no matter how high they raise their member dues.

Back to the original topic:

From reading Ms Z's comments, I believe she offers food for thought. For many of us old-timers it's the same cafeteria fare we've heard before. Yet her comments, or proposals if you prefer, would be of interest to folks who are new to the biz and may not have thought about the power of networking.

That being said, I would like to repeat a comment that Scott Susor posted some years ago when this perennial topic appeared: Certification is necessary for two scenarios ~ public safety and health. If an occupation does not directly affect either (or both) of these scenarios it will not be subject to certification of any nature.

One may ask why welders are certified. If someone is standing on a platform and the welds break, public safety is involved.

The same goes for firefighters, paramedics, auto technicians, plumbers, electricians and the medical field to mention a few. All of these trades or fields of practice are directly involved with public health and safety.

And then you have the food, pharmaceutical and medical device industries. They're under the auspices of the FDA. This aspect alone keeps 'em Made In USA. :)

Ms Z has great expectations. For whom I do not know. This crazy business is not an industry by definition. It's a broad definition of an undetermined number of individual wildcatters, each doing his or her own thing.

Attempting to certify and organize DJs is akin to herding cats. If one can make a buck by advising others on how to accomplish the task, good for him or her.

Hope it helps.
 
In my not so humble opinion certification isn’t worth a warm puddle of spit. From my previous posts you might have thought otherwise. You can test and certify, airline pilots, doctors, lawyers, massage therapists, certified beer judges, certified marina managers, acupuncturists, seed potatoes, INTERIOR DESIGNERS. PLEEASE don’t tell me you can’t certify a DJ.

YES, BUT I AM AN AR TEEEST. Last night, everybody agreed they were Djs and not entertainers now we are all intangibly skilled AR TEEESTS.

Certainly there are intangibles within a DJ’s skill set. Don’t test those, test the ones you can test. There are technical skills, knowledge about music and dance, customer relations, marketing and on and on. I could come up with one hell of a curriculum for a course of study. These are all part of the skill set. You want to assign 90% importance to that portion that is intangible, be my guest. That doesn’t mean someone will not come up with a program that tests the tangible and objective part of the skill set. You don’t like certification? Don’t cooperate. Don’t certify.

I can come up with a scheme to certify the person, the equipment and the library. You can certify one, you can certify all. Take your choice. Just because you can doesn’t make it a good idea. That brings us to the why. Most certifications benefit the certifying agency far more than it does the certified individual.

One way or the other, I’m not staying up nights worrying about any of it. If someone came up with a certification that I thought would put money in my pocket I’d certify. If not, I wouldn’t. People almost always act in their own self-interest. The comments made in this thread don’t change my opinion. Its not wrong it just is.

I agree with Fred. Herding cats, that's my line. Somehow when I hear ADJA and power in the same sentence it causes me to chuckle. But Fred, do interior designers effect health or safety? They're certified. Auto mechanics have their ASE's. You wanna say mechanics affect public safety? I say certify hamburger flippers they affect public health too. Hell, certify everybody.