If I've said it twice I've said it a million times...
Ill re-post this indepth evaluation/review I performed when I purchased the Bose system:
03/09/06
OK,
Last night I dropped some do-re-mi on a new PAS system: 2 sticks and 4 bass bins. I did so only because of the Guitar Center 30 day guarantee and for the following reasons and despite my reservations and experiences.
At the Guitar center and after a lengthy listen, to one stick and 2 bins, I thought the kicks, cymbals and vocals were sweet, I really like the look and size of the rig, I liked the fact that the gear came with protective covers and carry bags, and I am fully aware of the Bose reputation outside the pro audio community, IE. the world the clients live in. I also liked the idea of a more balanced volume level over a bigger space. I'm not sure this system truly accomplishes this despite the supporting claims, but I'm willing to learn. I also liked the speed at which the system broke down. The salesman, a knowledgeable guy, claimed set up was just as easy.
I didn't like somethings I heard. The mid & lower-mid bass seemed muddy at higher volumes and the very bottom was all but nuttless. The price, $4700, was a negative but I wanted to get my head around this new way of doing things, not to mention that any Guitar Center is a less than optimal environment to properly evaluate such a rig. Also, it didn't seem like the system was all that much smaller than a conventional 2 up/2 sub/2 amp system. Despite that, and the not so glowing evaluation of one of my dj's that was with me, I left with the system and plan to use the rig this Saturday at a mid-sized Barmitzvah.
When I got home I began unpacking the system. As you'd expect the stuff is well put together and attractive. The bags for the sticks and the bases were very good and looked nice. The covers for the bass bins were a little disappointing. Those covers are bottomless and seem like a pretty pitiful shortcut for such an expensive system. I'd have preferred, no, expected, given the price of the gear, a cover that protects all 6 sides. Minor but worth mentioning.
My first exercise was to determine the best way to load the cart with this new rig. I was very pleased that I could fit everything, including my coffin, on one cart load and with no discernible overload problems. Big points for this. If I were to organize, with more seriousness, my music into one or two Slappa 600 cases, I'd have no problem getting everything in on one trip. As it stands I'll need one gear run and one music run.
Unable and unwilling to wait till Saturday and curious as hell, I decided to set up the rig in my currently empty, awaiting furniture, den to give it a run with my source gear. I've done that.
The cables that come with the bass bins are way too short for dj use. They are sufficient is you place 2 bins by each stick. However, the system definitely sounded better, not great, but better with all four bricks centered and in a 2 x 2 config. The cables were too short for the necessary run. Minor point but worth mentioning. Set up was easy and relatively quick. Using current pop/radio/rap ish and a favorite sound check track from Seal, I am left hollow. The overdrive indicator came on way too soon and appeared overdriving the system would be easier than not. I hope my experience is different in the bigger venue this Saturday.
Just a note: Before we moved into this house, when construction was just completed and the place was practically empty, we had a Halloween party at which I set up my conventional system: same source gear (2xCDJ1K & a DJM600), two JBL MR925s, two EV S-181s, one Peavey CS800X and one Peavey CS1000s, crossed over at 100. The Bose system pales and fails in comparison. Seriously so in the sub-bass portion of the program and surprisingly so in the mid-bass regions.
First take: Conventional system leading by a mile. Unless the environment this Saturday reveals something I've missed, I'll be testing some new boxes next week. I really wanted the Bose stuff to live up to the proponent's claims and the price.
I'll report what I find after the gig.
2 B continued.
03/13/06
OK, here goes,
First I'll highlight the things the PAS system did very well.
1) The compact nature of the system was a blessing. I was able to get the entire system and music into the venue, with one trip. Saved me at least 15-20 minutes on load in/out. That's a very nice benefit.
2) The physical set-up was a breeze. 10 minutes after getting into the room I was doing a sound check. That's about 1/2 the amount of time of my conventional systems. Since time is valuable, I liked this a lot as well.
3) The venue manager liked the Bose system and commented how uncluttered the system looked. In other words, it made a nice impression. (My conventional systems have received similar comments) So, maybe a small benefit there.
4) In the unpopulated, with peeps, room, the sound was uniform, almost, both in sound quality and volume, across the entire space. There was still a noticeable difference on the dance floor, but not enough to be considered drastic or, from the layman's perspective, noticeable. I liked the fact that the volume was almost as loud enough in the back of the room as at the stage and I was still able to talk, anywhere in the room, without having to raise my voice in the slightest.
5) Either the system's phasing characteristics or the DSP capabilities allowed the microphone to be used directly in front of the speakers, (both sticks and subs) with no noticeable feedback, during the presentations, and without the the need for additional processing. I liked that.
6) Tear down was marginally less time consuming but definitely easier, a condition of being lighter and smaller. I liked the included transport bags. Loaded the Gemini Sr. hand truck, and one trip did the job. Again, time is money and this system saved time.
That's the main "+"s.
And now for something completely different:
And the reasons I'm returning the system, with some regret but mostly because of a concerted honest evaluation, and getting new conventional speakers.
1) Regardless of the settings, 57 or 00, there was never and there was never going to be enough bottom end to fill the space. And this was not a giant room. Theories are nice to discuss but Bose has always, as do guys with little cranks (lol), theorized that size doesn't matter. In the world of sound reproduction and female satisfaction, they are mistaken.
If you want to move big air, which serious low bass requires, you need 18", or at least 15". Eight 8" drivers are only greater than One 18" driver on a calculator, and generally I use two 18s. I'll put one of my EV S-181s against the four subs I used Saturday anywhere, anytime. When I hook up both S-181s, there ain't no competition.
2) Even the lower mid-bass frequencies were less present. I suspect that is because in the conventional system the 150-350 frequencies are reproduced with a 15" driver. Again, size matters.
3) When the floor was packed with younger dancers, they kept asking for it to be louder. I know they were really asking for more boom but I gave some more volume. I know that's not what the system is designed for, but it is what I needed and there was nothing left in the tank. The sound quality was noticeably degraded at the elevated volumes. The orange overdrive indicator lights were also scary. I never have to over drive my conventional systems.
4) I would have liked to spread the sticks out farther but the supplied cables were too short to keep the subs together in the most bass friendly configuration. I know there are longer cables available but for the price of the system, I really don't want to spend more on expensive proprietary-ish cables.
5) Based on Ken's (Petersen) wise and appreciated assistance, I used the supplied controllers to magically correct some issues that existed without them. And Ken was right. I did notice improvement when adding the controllers. However, I didn't like having to add another piece into the signal chain as it was just another thing to monitor. Very minor point but worth mentioning.
6) The system cost $4,700. While that is comparable, although higher, to the cost of my conventional bi-amped systems, from my evaluation it didn't provide enough flexibility or redundancy for the dollar. Since I already own way more than enough quality power amps, the costs of the PAS is double the costs of the conventional options I have available. And that's for JBL/EV/Turbosound gear. And not the entry level line either.
Synopsis: For me the things I liked about the PAS system could not overcome the things I didn't. The convenience and uniform sound of the Bose stuff could not overcome the total spectrum sound quality and bass output that my conventional systems have provided me for over the last 20+ years in this racket. In the end the it as all about the sound.
I'd like to thank Ken for his assistance. It was truly a generous act on his part to help me in my evaluation. I suspect that the proponent's of the PAS system simply have different needs for their gigs than I do. That's why there are markets for Chevrolet Suburbans and Honda Pilots. You can't get a sheet of plywood in Pilot but you can in a Suburban. However it is possible to drive past a gas station in Pilot, in a Suburban, different story.
I hope my experience/experiment/exercise is helpful in quashing some of the debate and that it can assist other with their equipment decisions. As they say in Frogtopia, "Vive Le Difference!"
_________________
Rocky Bourg
Dad/Husband/Son/Brother/American/Wyzazz
(985)807-6259