Question About The Bose PAS

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

Mr. K

New DJ
Aug 7, 2006
4,215
0
Just Curious

What would happen if you ran a PAS system and a standard one side by side? Let's say both systems are the same wattage.

I'm imagining that it would be really loud close to the speakers but, as you move away from the range of the standard system, the PAS sound continues on?

Or, would there be some sort of sound cancellation going on?

Eh? I dunno, but I am really curious.
 
I think you would defeat youre purpose on both ends of the spectrum
 
An A-B comparison would not be entirely fair to either system because they are different system types.

The L1 or PAS is a near-field line array system. It is promoted to musicians and small live act combos for near-field purposes. It cannot be honestly compared to a conventional PA system.

Each system type has its uses.

Hope it helps.
 
I've never tried it, Johnny.

The closest I've come is conventional system in one room, L1s in another.

Same guests, same music, same volume levels, same source of signals, Thru-outputs in use (not zone outs), and guests easily allowed to travel one room to the next, as was I with a mic.

The non-L1 room was side-by-side a nightmare. The two systemes are dramatically differant in propagations.
 
Let's say both systems are the same wattage.

I'm imagining that it would be really loud close to the speakers but, as you move away from the range of the standard system, the PAS sound continues on?

Is this a likely possibility?

Or would things just sound funny?

My purpose is experimentation. I'm not really trying to compare them. This is, of course, theoretical. I don't understand enough, so I need a "Yes/No/I dunno" answer.

Thanks, guys. And I'm a geek. I don't mean DAN geek. I mean GEEK geek.

:)
 
I think with the throw patterns of the different systems, that it would sound muddy all around. That is my guess.
 
I would expect you would get an echo from delay also because of the difference in the way they throw
 
This is not a yes /no/I dunno...

But it might be interesting to find out.

But I would wonder why would someone do this.
Maybe if they had a real big gig, 700 or 800 people and wanted to be sure I guess...

I know some guys who bring a Mackie sub with the L1 system because they want more bass,,,, but other than that........
 
But I would wonder why would someone do this.
Maybe if they had a real big gig, 700 or 800 people and wanted to be sure I guess...

Here's why (sorta like what you said, and what I eluded to, though it would be a fruitless effort by the sounds of it):

You wanna blast a small somewhat enclosed area but you want a nice consistent sound because the entire venue is huge. Or something like that.

And, for the sake of experimenting.
 
Thanks again, guys.

Jeff: not fair because you should not just keep replying to my questions just to build up your THANK YOUs. :p

LOL I Gotta catch up to you somehow
 
The Vinyl Spinner :
What would happen if you ran a PAS system and a standard one side by side? Let's say both systems are the same wattage
Apples and oranges, Vinyl.

The L1, with 24 drivers, matched internal passive eq, matched internal DSP, matched internal amplifiers, does not require the higher power (amplifier output) requirements of traditional spherical speakers to perform its tasks.
 
The Vinyl Spinner :
Apples and oranges, Vinyl.

The L1, with 24 drivers, matched internal passive eq, matched internal DSP, matched internal amplifiers, does not require the higher power (amplifier output) requirements of traditional spherical speakers to perform its tasks.

Cap,

What is a traditional spherical speaker?

What is the difference between a traditional spherical speaker and a L1 driver?

How much power does a single L1 use?

What is the maximum DB output of a single L1 at full power?

What is the DB output of a typical traditional 15" spherical speaker at the same rated maximum power of an L1?

Using all 24 drivers in an L1 what is a direct comparision to a typical 15" speakers parameters?
 
Steve Miller : I'd be glad to chat about all this on the phone any time, or if a discussion with a degreed experienced engineer is preferred, I'll hook you up with someone at BOSE who designed and built the system.

Unfortunately, previous history elsewhere precludes my desire to get into anything other than my personal opinion and personal experience as a BOSE user in terms of mobile DJ work. Thankfully, this forum does have the ignore feature which has been utilized so as to avoid previous encounters of the worst kind.

My number is 518 399-7451 or 866-999-7451 (Eastern Time Zone)

I'm not here as a BOSE Rep but as a representative of my life's passion, a full-time career mobile DJ.
 
Cap,

I thought here you would have an opportunity to give an honest look at what Bose offers without the hype. All I know about the Bose PAS system is it's purported power output and max SPL. What I was asking was how does it compare in SPL to one 15" conventional unit using the same amount of power. How many 2 inch speakers it requires to move the same amount of air that a typical 15" can move.

Cap I am not looking to Bash Bose, just understand it. You and I both know that Bose will not release any specs on the PAS system to the general public I would have that thought as a rep of Bose that you would have better access to that information.

Perhaps you may want to rethink your ignore feature for this site. Give everyone a new shot here and see where it leads maybe there will be a much better understanding here.
 
Steve : All I know for sure is how the BOSE L1 enhances the audio side of my performances, with unending audience, client, and facility staff compliments about the system's sound quality and propagation. Every complaint ever experienced in the previous 25 years in this busines using JBL, Peavey, FBT, and BOSE [802/502/302] has been totally eradicated. Gone. None. This is my personal experience, no hype.

It would not be fair of me to overstep the respected boundries of the kind welcome here to promote a side business that is outside of mobile DJ unless I was a paying sponsor.
 
Thank you Steve.

So 24-2" drivers in each PAS column.

Care to help me out with same info re: the associated B-1 bass boxes?
 
In all seriousness couldn't you apply algebra to the equation... PI?
3.141592654?

1 Bose: 24 * 2" * 3.141 = 150.768" Area
1 15": 15 * 1 * 3.141 = 47.115" Area

somehow that should equate to sound pressure.... my math is a little flawed though, this was a real one sided equation.
 
Travis,

It should, and I'd think it does. But, like you, I don't quite know how to quantify it.

I suspect what may be missing is the push of air that is caused by the actual piston action of the cones. Our 24 little guys (if you were to look at just one) have such a small amount actual "in-n-out" movement. Whereas that one 15" cone has a measurable "in-n-out." Caught in that 'bowl-shape' of the 15" cone is the beginning of the air movement that would start the SPL measurments, and the crux of the Bose L1 vs the world debate of SPL's.

dB's in volume may be equalled. But the SPLs would more than likely be less.

Now, upon that statement, maybe a sound engineer/guru can help me out.

Why can a guest walk in front of an L1 at 95 dB and not "duck" or wince. But the same guest can walk in front of a 15" cone at 95 dB and plug their ear, "duck" and wince?

Me thinks that answer lies somewhere in SPL's.