What bitrate are you using to encode your mp3's?

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!
I would argue that it's the treble that takes a major hit the lower the bitrate goes. Bass too, but in my experience, it's the high end that suffers most. The resulting sound is limited bandwidth like an AM signal.

And you see, the point we agree on is my entire point about using as high a bitrate as possible on a DJ rig, unless your system is not very high end (high resolution)!

A few years back I was exclusively using 160k MP3s. I couldn't tell the difference between the MP3s and CDs. I had our main engineer & our music programmer out at different events and did a side-by-side with them (because they said they'd be able to hear the difference). They weren't able to tell the difference either.

I think each DJ has their own opinion of 'high-end' system but I think my system at the time (which is the same system I run now) is pretty good. I use a Rane MP44 mixer, QSC PLX 3402 mixer & EV SX-300 speakers.

Is that system not high-end enough to be able to tell the difference between low quality MP3 & CDs?
 
A few years back I was exclusively using 160k MP3s. I couldn't tell the difference between the MP3s and CDs. I had our main engineer & our music programmer out at different events and did a side-by-side with them (because they said they'd be able to hear the difference). They weren't able to tell the difference either.

I think each DJ has their own opinion of 'high-end' system but I think my system at the time (which is the same system I run now) is pretty good. I use a Rane MP44 mixer, QSC PLX 3402 mixer & EV SX-300 speakers.

Is that system not high-end enough to be able to tell the difference between low quality MP3 & CDs?
In a noisy environment it is far less likely that someone would be able to hear a difference unless the sources were encoded with ridiculously low bit rates. What I was referring to was the low-budget equipment such as Realistic and things like that which you typically find non-serious beer-money people using.

I have no idea if your system is high-end enough, Jim. I haven't heard it. Reciting brand names and model numbers doesn't advance the argument, but I'm pretty sure your QSC unit is an amplifier! ;)
 
Doh! I've been listening to my mp3s at 320 and not happy at all... I ripped using normalization and I think that ruined some and helped others.... dang it.... i'm gonna rip to wav w/o normalization then encode to mp3 320.... lessen learned.... don't get me wrong they are ok... but i'm a little nerotic when it comes to quality.
 
Let me add a secret piece to the puzzle. If the original format is of low quality yes even on Vinyl or on CD the end results cant improve no matter the bitrate. Food for thought!!
 
In computereze, it's Garbage In, Garbage Out!
 
Bryan
COMPUTEREZE>????? I dont find any dictionary recognizing that as a word though it would be an acceptable score count in Scrabble if it were.
 
which you typically find non-serious beer-money people using.

I resemble that -- as Fred would say... :sqwink: :sqlaugh:


I test my stuff using studio amps, with studio monitors. Freq. response is roughly 10-100Khz on the amps, 18-50, or thereabouts on the monitors.

I have yet to find anyone who can tell the diff between a 320 MP3, and a CD in a fairly quiet environment.The firmware on the CD player, is also a factor.

In my listening room, running all tube (amps, CD player, pre-amp), yes, you can tell. But, that costs more than most folk's houses, and it would take a few days to bring it to a gig, and warm everything up.


I'm getting ready to pull the floor downstairs in the bar, replace it, and build a new showroom and listening room this spring. It will give folks the opportunity, to hear in different environments and noise floors. It's not really a place to showcase my products, more of a "My Room" place, so once completed, I hope many will come and enjoy :)

I am sooo tired of hearing the argument, that I am willing to invest the money to put the matter to rest :sqbiggrin:
 
Bryan
COMPUTEREZE>????? I dont find any dictionary recognizing that as a word though it would be an acceptable score count in Scrabble if it were.
Alright, so much for my little wordplay... "Computerese." No, "Computereeze." No, wait, "Compooterease." Wait, wait... :sqlaugh:
 
In a noisy environment it is far less likely that someone would be able to hear a difference unless the sources were encoded with ridiculously low bit rates. What I was referring to was the low-budget equipment such as Realistic and things like that which you typically find non-serious beer-money people using.

I have no idea if your system is high-end enough, Jim. I haven't heard it. Reciting brand names and model numbers doesn't advance the argument, but I'm pretty sure your QSC unit is an amplifier! ;)

The enviornment for the side-by-side blind test wasn't noisy...it was before the event started.

I guess I'm confused as to how you can say only 'high-end' equipment can you tell the difference but you can't qualify what high-end equipment is. If that's the case, you can't really say 'only on high-end equipment'. It seems it would be appropriate to say in your opinion 'on some systems' you can tell the difference.

I'd love to see a blind test done sometime at a DJ convention. There are so many DJs who say they can tell the difference I think it would be interesting to see how accurate they are.
 
I guess I'm confused as to how you can say only 'high-end' equipment can you tell the difference but you can't qualify what high-end equipment is. If that's the case, you can't really say 'only on high-end equipment'. It seems it would be appropriate to say in your opinion 'on some systems' you can tell the difference.
I guess I'm confused as to how you can say that I said "only 'high-end'" anything. I never said that.

Jim, if I need to qualify what high-end equipment is for you, we're in serious trouble. I think you're just picking for a fight, and I'm not going to take the bait.