Import karaoke will take over the US market.

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

toqer

New DJ
Feb 1, 2007
426
0
53
So my latest blog post at Numark has been posted. I'm amazed, they posted it without editing a single word.

http://www.numark.com/content37465

Import karaoke will take over the US market.

So a lot of you KJ's are probably scratching your heads wondering what ol' toq means by this statement. Let me explain. If you look at where the karaoke market is in it's entirety, it closely resembles that of the plain music market 10 years ago. Let's flashback 10 years.

Ten years ago was when the first P2P applications began to emerge. Napster was at the height of its popularity. We started seeing brick and mortar music stores close up shop. Every label in existence was trying to squash what seemed like a rampant, undulating tide of piracy. Fast-forward to the present.

Napster got shutdown (only to be reborn as a legitimate subscription service) Labels are slowly getting used to the idea that there is money in digital downloads. iTunes and the iPod did a lot to change the labels perception that digital media was evil. While the music labels have made the switch to digital media, the majority of karaoke publishers have not. The same fair-use arguments we heard 10 years ago when it came to MP3's are starting to resurface again, with mostly American karaoke labels leading the charge to keep us in the dark ages of karaoke technology.

At the forefront of this battle in America is the Karaoke Anti-piracy Agency (K.A.P.A). http://www.karaokeantipiracyagency.com/ <http://www.karaokeantipiracyagency.com/> . KAPA is the amalgamation of several US based karaoke labels. Their mission, sue any KJ using a PC and try to have PC based karaoke obliterated. It doesn't matter if a KJ is only using karaoke they have original disks for, or if they're pirating tens of thousands of songs. They're the same in KAPA's eyes. KAPA would like to see us all back on CDG's, buying disks through their old distribution chains and buying hardware from companies in which they hold an active interest.

The funny thing is, some of the members of the KAPA agency do indeed have some form of digital karaoke, but if you're familiar with the term "Vendor lock in" you already know what the score is. Basically the KAPA members that support digital karaoke want you to buy their proprietary formats, on their proprietary hardware. You would think they would have taken a hint from what the labels went through 10 years ago, but they do not.

The stance taken by KAPA is a very stark contrast to what major UK labels have decided to do. Zoom karaoke was one of the first to start offering digital downloads of it's catalog in standard MP3+G format. The tracks are on par with even the best American karaoke label (we all know who that is right?).

Following in Zooms footsteps is SBI karaoke, another UK based karaoke producers. They too have started publishing and selling their song catalog online.

There are other companies starting to sell karaoke online as well. From this KJ's perspective, there is nothing more satisfying than being able to tell a customers "I don't have your song, but I can download it for $1.99." Most of the time I add a dollar markup, and keep the extra buck for myself. This is my incentive to not pirate. For every song I don't own, I can make a buck. Considering there are probably 1000's of songs I don't own, and 1000's of new songs coming out every year, I don't think I'll ever have to worry about running out of songs people want to buy for my collection.

So I don't pirate a thing, and I make an extra few bucks from it each night. Go me for doing the right thing.

I think this concept will catch on in many KJ'ing markets. I know for a fact that some software companies are currently trying to work with these publishers to make these types of purchases with KJ markup even easier to implement.

Now before any American karaoke company accuses me of "Not knowing what the situation is" let me tell you this:
I've talked to many of you on the phone, at NAMM, in e-mails.
The situation is the whole "Sync License" issue, where karaoke is considered an "audiovisual" work like a movie, making distribution and licensing a whole lot messier.

So bearing in mind that toqer does understand the situation and grasp what's going on in its entirety, let me make a suggestion to the karaoke companies: Instead of treating your users like criminals and starting an organization like KAPA, why don't you take all that money and effort to congress? Have them change copyright so that CDG or any kind of karaoke is in the same category as regular music.

Let me paint out a few scenarios of how this can all play out.

Scenario A:
US karaoke publishers decide to fight the tide of import digital karaoke. This will never happen. There are several issues that will make this impossible for you. Net Neutrality is the first thing that will prevent it.

Net Neutrality is the idea that Internet traffic should flow freely, and it's up to the destination user how that traffic should be filtered. The US could setup firewalls to block all imported digital karaoke but it will never happen. In this country, freedom of speech and freedom of information are constitutionally protected.

The other problem with fighting import digital karaoke is jurisdiction. While you might be able to knock down a fellow American company willing to take the chance on selling digital karaoke, those same laws you used in that situation won't apply to an overseas company. You will never be able to convince the out of US companies to filter out American IP traffic. It's very simple for them to do so, but it will never happen.

Scenario B:
US karaoke publishers decide to go for digital karaoke sales. U.S. companies decide to band together and just start selling stuff online. KAPA gets a new mission statement supporting digital downloads and ripping purchased media to a hard drive. Each KAPA member contributes to a "Lobbying/Defense" fund in case some music label gets a hair up their ass and decides to sue them. KAPA begins lobbying congress to update the copyright laws so that karaoke isn't grouped into the same category as movies.

With either scenario being played out within the next year or two, it's going to be interesting to see what choice the US karaoke companies decide to go with. Either way, it's going to be a long uphill battle for them.

If they go with Scenario A, they can count on losing the support of their customers. Import karaoke wins. If they go with Scenario B, I'm sure every single customer will support them, not only by just purchasing songs but in every imaginable way possible including writing their congress, and donating money to the KAPA agency.

As I said earlier, right now I have a viable financial incentive to not pirate karaoke in my collection. If the U.S. karaoke producers really want to squash karaoke piracy, they need to look into this instead of putting the blame on the digital portion of the karaoke scene. You can't force people to stop pirating. For the majority of karaoke pirates, money is the #1 factor in steering them towards a life of stealing tracks.

So draw on what motivates them to pirate, and use it for your benefit. Use them to your benefit. Offer us the same choice to do the right thing that import karaoke companies have. Otherwise you're going to see even more sales lost to import karaoke.

KARAOKE IS HARDCORE!!!
--toqer
 
Now I see why you're PC based- you love typing!!:sqlaugh:


OK, fooling around aside, I agree with you, simply because it's happened so many times before in different media.


Remember when you could only watch a movie at the theatre- and a single screen theatre made money? Now only the little screen multiplexes can stay open. Why? Because....


.....Remember when you had to go to the video rental store to rent or buy a movie? They were so successful that they knocked the theatre industry on it's butt. Now video rental stores are closing all over the place
Why? Because......


.....Remember when you waited for the mail and your rental/newly bought movie? Rare, nowadays. Why? Because........

.....You can download the movie or buy it while checking out your groceries. However, since you can now lock and download from your cable or satellite provider, pretty soon you'll be sayng "Remember when...."


Toq, though you're probably right, I wouldn't be too happy about it. This is what causes the economy problems we have now. Yes, it's more convenient, but with every "upgrade" less and less money is made per song. The sellers, like the video people, have to rely on TREMENDOUS volume sales to stay in business. If they can't generate these sales they close. Why should we care? 1) There are fewer and fewer "replacement" companies and sources. 2) Since the US now depends on information rather than manufacturing for it's economy, the devalueing of this asset will (actually already has) really do a number on the economy. And if the imports take over- MORE money out of the country. This has already happened with software, video, and straight music. Karaoke is just the last holdout.

In the very short term we will reap the benefits, but in the long term, we will pay- in all parts of our daily living. Oh yeah: Zoom really IS a terrific mfr.
 
Actually Joe, we're going to make more money in the long run...

Think about all the things that could be sold if the licensing was setup correctly.

You know those bad KJ's that burn free copies of CDG's for customers? What if you could legitimately electronically pay a fee to burn a disk for a customer. Charge your own markup. Kaching! Sale.

You know all the controversy surrounding KJ's that give a singer a copy of their performance? What if you could legitimately electronically pay a fee and charge the customer your own markup? Kaching! Sale!

I've already demonstrated those songs I don't own are a Kaching! Sale!

What all this is going to do is level the entire playing field. No more urination contests seeing who has the most songs. It will truly be KJ skill at that point.
 
It's a long post that seems to go off-topic, but stick with me, please. :)

Former US Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan talks about "creative destruction," an economic theory that states (in its simplest form) that as technology advances, there are great economic & industrial transformations that follow. As transformations occur, jobs (and entire industries) are destroyed but others are created in their place. For instance, as automation crept into the automobile industry, fewer workers were needed to assemble the actual vehicles, but others were needed to program, build, monitor & troubleshoot the automated systems. Totally different jobs, but jobs that were created as others were lost.

Joe, your post about the film industry is a perfect example of that. As consumers demand different ways to get their entertainment, some industries & their workers suffer (theaters, rental stores) and others have been created or adapted to meet the changes in demand (Netflix, Blockbuster, iTunes Video). In the long run, the consumer does actually benefit.
JoeChartreuse said:
1) There are fewer and fewer "replacement" companies and sources.
There are currently four major record labels in the U.S. - Warner Music, Sony/BMG, Universal & EMI. I'm sure you could name other "labels," but few are truly independent from these four. They own over 70% of the global music market. Their parent companies also dominate broadcast and cable TV, film production and distribution, & news gathering and distribution. What you "foresee" happening in the karaoke industry has already happened - smaller companies are already gone. (Top Tunes, DK, Music Maestro...)
JoeChartreuse said:
2) Since the US now depends on information rather than manufacturing for it's economy, the devalueing of this asset will (actually already has) really do a number on the economy.
If companies truly value the "information" they supply, they have ways to protect it, and they will always find ways to make money from it. Intellectual property (IP) rights still exist; the [SIZE=-1]Digital Millennium Copyright Act affirmed that a change in distribution format doesn't change the value of IP. The asset itself isn't devalued, it's just cheaper to distribute.

So, the industries here threatened with destruction? Brick-and-mortar karaoke shops, CDG manufacturers, and CDG player manufacturers. The industries here that have been created? MP3+G licensors & distributors; MP3+G player developers, manufacturers, & distributors; and MP3+G download services. The demand for the product still exists (karaoke with graphics), we just demand it in a different format. Either way, we pay money to get the product legally and the industry survives if it's able to adapt. It actually costs more to get the product (U.S.$1.99 per song instead of U.S.$15-$22 per 15-song CDG), but it's more efficient since we aren't buying the one song we need along with a dozen others we don't need. (20th version of "Sweet Home Alabama," anyone?) Therefore, the consumer does benefit in the long-run.
[/SIZE]
 
Excelant post Kayleigh I couldn't have said it any better...

I believe that the manu's have a simular parinoid delusion that digital downloads will be the downfall of their business... and maybe it will be, but only if they continue to refuse to adapt to the not so new technologies that they have so valently dug their heals in to prevent the inevidable changes.

While toqer's post did seem to ramble a bit there are some very good points. Same goes for Joe's post.

What many posters, myself included, do is take a narrow view and usually it's a view that doesn't see the big picture.

So here it is IMHO, digital karaoke and music is here to stay. It's not going away and it certainly is going to only get better and easier to obtain in legal manners. What remains to be seen is which companies will remain after the dust settles.
 
Actually Joe, we're going to make more money in the long run...

Think about all the things that could be sold if the licensing was setup correctly.

You know those bad KJ's that burn free copies of CDG's for customers? What if you could legitimately electronically pay a fee to burn a disk for a customer. Charge your own markup. Kaching! Sale.

You know all the controversy surrounding KJ's that give a singer a copy of their performance? What if you could legitimately electronically pay a fee and charge the customer your own markup? Kaching! Sale!

I've already demonstrated those songs I don't own are a Kaching! Sale!

What all this is going to do is level the entire playing field. No more urination contests seeing who has the most songs. It will truly be KJ skill at that point.


The same flaw here as in the gun laws. The bad KJs (not Karaoke Hosts) already sell copied discs at almost pure profit. If they don't care about stealing the music in the first place, they don't care about selling it either. Same with recorded performances.

Will legitimate hosts make some more money from proper licensing? Sure. But if the US economy keeps heading for the crapper,( and it will as long as information is devalued this way and we don't come up with new hard technology to generate income)) those "profits" will be flushed away in the cost of daily living. No long term gain, and probable loss.
 
The same flaw here as in the gun laws. The bad KJs (not Karaoke Hosts) already sell copied discs at almost pure profit. If they don't care about stealing the music in the first place, they don't care about selling it either. Same with recorded performances.

Will legitimate hosts make some more money from proper licensing? Sure. But if the US economy keeps heading for the crapper,( and it will as long as information is devalued this way and we don't come up with new hard technology to generate income)) those "profits" will be flushed away in the cost of daily living. No long term gain, and probable loss.

Ohh for cripe sake do you buy into all the propaganda that KAPA and Sound Choice puts out.... jeez you sound like your a representative of their war machine....

That post was such hooey I just don't know where to start....

Our economy isn't going into the crapper because of digital media... quite the oposite... digital media will bring most manu's out of the crapper. Hard media is dead plan and simple. It is no longer a viable solution anymore. Digital media in no way devalues the industry it just provides a method of recieving the music faster and more efficiently... I mean lets face it how many copies of Margaritaville do we really need. I for one am sick of buying a disc of 15 songs with the one song I want and 14 duplicate songs... with digital media sure I pay more per song but I get what I need and not what I don't... that is value to me.
 
The same flaw here as in the gun laws. The bad KJs (not Karaoke Hosts) already sell copied discs at almost pure profit. If they don't care about stealing the music in the first place, they don't care about selling it either. Same with recorded performances.

Will legitimate hosts make some more money from proper licensing? Sure. But if the US economy keeps heading for the crapper, (and it will as long as information is devalued this way and we don't come up with new hard technology to generate income) those "profits" will be flushed away in the cost of daily living. No long term gain, and probable loss.
Digital media doesn't cause devaluation, pirates cause devaluation. Music that is legally licensed and legally obtained (i.e. paid for through legitimate distribution channels) maintains the value of pre-recorded music.

I don't agree that the US economy isn't going into the "crapper" due to a "devaluation" of intellectual property or technology, as you claim. It's due to a devaluation of US currency, due, in part, to the international markets. 1) They lack confidence in the US economy in the short-term and 2) they get smaller returns on the US dollar because our interest rates are going down for the foreseeable future - to get bigger (and maybe more stable) returns, they sell US currency & buy other currencies. It's also due to banks' creative financing of sub-par mortgage debt, which was inaccurately valued and overpriced to start with. Now, they are giving back their gains from the over-valued junk by "writing off" their losses. (Unfortunately, they're dragging down the value of every American with them, but that's a whole other discussion.)

So, rounding back to Toqer's original discussion, if US karaoke manufacturers drop from the market, we'll get our karaoke from foreign sources. With the value of the US dollar dropping, it will actually cost MORE for us to get legally licensed, legally purchased karaoke music. Instead of US$1.99 per song, we'll be paying ?1.50 - over US$3.00 - per song. Is THAT enough devaluation?
 
I think Joe's point was pirating KJ's are going to pirate no matter what.

What motivates them to pirate Joe? The feeling of getting something for nothing? I dunno...

That's going to be the whole point of the initiative i'll be helping to spearhead with the companies i'll be working with. We want to take that "Something for nothing" attitude and use it to the karaoke manufacturers benefit.

A lot of what we're going to be doing is removing what little manual processes are left in what I do, and making it fully automatic. Instead of a customer givin me a few bucks, they can swipe their credit card (or use a bill validator/cash) to purchase goods and services on the spot via the kiosk box.

Preliminary features of the new software:
Spits out DVD's/VCD's/CD's of performances for a price.
Spits out CDG's for a price
Allows a customer to purchase songs for the venue

And for all of the above, the only way one of these pirating KJ's is going to be able to deliver all these services is to "Get with the program" so to speak.

You'll be able to access any karaoke song from any vendor. Do they want SGB or SC Sweet Caroline added to the collection? Yah, you'll be able to "Offer" it all. Not quite the same as having it all, but almost as good.

With PC tech there's a lot of little PITA things that you have to do. Naming conventions for one. We plan on eliminating all these little meanial tasks for the KJ.

Finally I want to point out that yeah, the criminals will still be criminals, but for the average person using our system will be 100x easier than stealing karaoke.

It's easier, and you kind of get paid for using it.

We'll see a big reduction in KJ piracy due to this. I mean, why bother stealing it if you're going to have to make sure the naming is perfect, the rip is perfect, and all the other little nagging details are perfect when going legit will be easier and more profitable?

This has probably been said a million times over in the music debate. "If you buy the original CD you get cover art, lyric sheets, etc." We plan on offering such huge rewards for going legit, it's going to blow your mind. It's gonna make crappy printed jewel case inserts look like a joke.

Example...

It would cost us nothing to create a chart based on sales logs of "Who's purchased the most songs!" It gets to the very core of the "I have 60,000 songs" penis measuring contest.

There's other mineable data as well. We could mine data based on Genre to list which karaoke venues do the most spanish karaoke, or which venue picks the most 80's songs.

You don't get listed if you're not getting with the program either. No free marketing for pirates.

I'm gonna stop because this is getting silly and rantish. You get the whole idea though, we're gonna make it easier, more rewarding, and more profitable to go legit. No stupid enforcement agencies or FBI needed.
 
1) Totally different jobs, but jobs that were created as others were lost.......

2) others have been created or adapted to meet the changes in demand (Netflix, Blockbuster, iTunes Video). In the long run, the consumer does actually benefit.


3) If companies truly value the "information" they supply, they have ways to protect it, and they will always find ways to make money from it. Intellectual property (IP) rights still exist; the [SIZE=-1]Digital Millennium Copyright Act affirmed that a change in distribution format doesn't change the value of IP. The asset itself isn't devalued, it's just cheaper to distribute.

4) So, the industries here threatened with destruction? Brick-and-mortar karaoke shops, CDG manufacturers, and CDG player manufacturers. The industries here that have been created? MP3+G licensors & distributors; MP3+G player developers, manufacturers, & distributors; and MP3+G download services.


1) No, I'm afraid the old jobs haven't been replaced. A few new jobs may have been created, but there just is no need for as many employees for an online service is there were for "bick and morter" companies.



2,3,4) ANYTHING that exists on line, unfortunately, is free for the taking by the unscrupulous. It's just a matter of knowing how. Also, the devaluation DOES exist, as shown by that 1.99 price tag that you mentioned. Think of the VOLUME that must be sold to stimulate the economy the way that the more expensive hard media did. Yes, it's great for us pros-for now- but ALL of us will be paying it back in the very near future. There is virtually NOTHING left in the US on which to base a stable ( forget growing ) economy. No, on-line song are cetainly not the big tip-over, just another straw on the camel's back.
 
Hmmmm.... you say it'd take more $1.99 sales to equal 1 sale of a disc... well lets just look at that why don't we....

Single disc moderately priced at $25 which contains typically 20 tracks.... say all those tracks are wanted and not duplicating what a KJ already has... If he order's it he has to wait for it to arrive... if he goes to a store to buy it he has to expend gas to go get it.

Let's give the time he had to wait for it some value... say for giggles $3

or Gas say $3.50

now that CD has cost him a minimum of $28 bucks....

Then he has to waste time converting to mp3+G

Now take that same CD but in digital single track availability for instant download.... already in the format that he needs.

20 x $1.99 = $39.80

I ask you between $28 and $39.80 where is the devaluation?

I'd say the manu's would be making out better then ever before... wouldn't you?
 
A lot of what we're going to be doing is removing what little manual processes are left in what I do, and making it fully automatic. Instead of a customer givin me a few bucks, they can swipe their credit card


*****Allows a customer to purchase songs for the venue

You'll be able to access any karaoke song from any vendor. Do they want SGB or SC Sweet Caroline added to the collection? Yah, you'll be able to "Offer" it all. Not quite the same as having it all, but almost as good.

With PC tech there's a lot of little PITA things that you have to do. Naming conventions for one. We plan on eliminating all these little meanial tasks for the KJ.


Hey Toq, as for most of the above: What are they going to need you and me for?

****** Buy songs for the venue? Toq, I have to remind you that your situation is unique. In standard bars NOBODY buys songs for the venue- it's the hosts' job to supply the music, and part of what we offer to the venue. If a customer wants a song for themselves, that means they want to sing it outside of your venue.

I'm sorry Toq, I kmow you put on a great show, but your experience is with one place that is far outside the standard, giving a view of the business that is, quite possibly, detrimental to karaoke hosts working a standard venue.

No flame intended- you know that I respect your abilities, and I know that you are a dedicated host. I just think that an expansion of horizons and experiences may be of benefit.
 
Hey Toq, as for most of the above: What are they going to need you and me for?

****** By songs for the venue? Toq, I have to remind you that your situation is unique. In standard bars NOBODY buys songs for the venue- that's the host's job, and part of what we offer to the venue. If a ustomer wants a song for themselves, that means they want to sing it outside of your venue.

I'm sorry Toq, I kmow you put on a great show, but your experience is with one place that is far outside the standard, giving a view of the business that is, quite possibly, detrimental to karaoke hosts working a standard venue.

No flame intended- you know that I respect your abilities, and I know that you are a dedicated host. I just think that an expansion of horizons and experiences may be of benefit.

I agree with you to a point... yeah most people aren't going to go out of their way to buy music for the host... but for that one PITA turd that has to have the song RIGHT NOW with toqer's solution it's available... heck even without that PITA a kj can easily supliment his own collection legally on the spot and make people happy..... and isn't that the goal anyway?
 
I'm sorry Toq, I kmow you put on a great show, but your experience is with one place that is far outside the standard.

Joe we need to do what we can to support the manu's at this point. How is the state of karaoke in your area? Do you see pirates? I sure do...

We're always going to be needed Joe, someone has to facilitate the fun :sqerr:
 
Hmmmm.... you say it'd take more $1.99 sales to equal 1 sale of a disc... well lets just look at that why don't we....

Single disc moderately priced at $25 which contains typically 20 tracks.... say all those tracks are wanted and not duplicating what a KJ already has... If he order's it he has to wait for it to arrive... if he goes to a store to buy it he has to expend gas to go get it.

Let's give the time he had to wait for it some value... say for giggles $3

or Gas say $3.50

now that CD has cost him a minimum of $28 bucks....

Then he has to waste time converting to mp3+G

Now take that same CD but in digital single track availability for instant download.... already in the format that he needs.

20 x $1.99 = $39.80

I ask you between $28 and $39.80 where is the devaluation?

I'd say the manu's would be making out better then ever before... wouldn't you?


Yes and no. First, the MFR. only gets 21.50 of that 28..oo

On the other hand, the MFR. does make more of a net profit because it doesn't have to keep reproducing the music. So the president and a few officers of the company make much more money. That's the problem.

Companies LOVE your way of thinking for just that reason. With so many employees laid off, the COMPANY makes more, with the money going into the pockets of the few, rather than spread through a large work force. Though the company profits, many are left jobless, making no contribution to the economy. Any contribution the lucky few makes is offset by unemployment and welfare benefits. The economy suffers. So more companies downsize to make more, laying off MORE workers to draw more subsidies, etc... etc...

Again, I'm certainly not blaming online music for all of the U.S.'s economic woes, but it IS the thinking behind it - being applied to many, many businesses- that IS the cause.
 
Yes and no. First, the MFR. only gets 21.50 of that 28..oo

On the other hand, the MFR. does make more of a net profit because it doesn't have to keep reproducing the music. So the president and a few officers of the company make much more money. That's the problem.

Companies LOVE your way of thinking for just that reason. With so many employees laid off, the COMPANY makes more, with the money going into the pockets of the few, rather than spread through a large work force. Though the company profits, many are left jobless, making no contribution to the economy. Any contribution the lucky few makes is offset by unemployment and welfare benefits. The economy suffers. So more companies downsize to make more, laying off MORE workers to draw more subsidies, etc... etc...

Again, I'm certainly not blaming online music for all of the U.S.'s economic woes, but it IS the thinking behind it - being applied to many, many businesses- that IS the cause.

Well gee isn't that what they are in business for is to make money or have employees sucking from their bottom line...

Sure some employee's are gonna either have to get more tech savy or lose their jobs that's just a part of doing business... as processes change, for good or worse, people have to change as well. Sure that press operator might lose his job and sure that shipping clerk might too.... I highly doubt in the big scheme of things a handfull of "blue color labor" might be lost... believe me McDonalds is always hireing... as far as losing their nickel in the economy it's a very microscoping drop in the economic bucket.

For every job lost due to advances in technology a new one is opened by technology.... lets face it as technology advances so does the necesity for individuals with higher education to not only program but also repair and maintain the systems involved in the process....

I don't think CDG's or CD's will go away... after all they still make vinyl and even cassette tapes... there will always be a market for hard media albiet a smaller one.

As far as the economy in general goes... as tech advances so do salaries for those that have the knowlege to create and maintain these new systems...

Losing a handfull of minimum wage jobs isn't going to make or break the economy and for every lost job one or two are created for folks with a higher tech knowlege and usually for more money.

Speeding up the distrabution channels be they digital or brick and mortor will only go to expand the economy at some level. Continueing with contrived and outdated distrabution will only drag the "economy" further in the whole because of it's inablity to keep up with demands....
 
Let me put it this way...

Say I'm in the business of making widgets...

Say this widget is made of 20 parts and each part required a separate employee making minimum wage to put each piece together on my widget. Additionally it takes 1 to package and 1 to pack and 1 to ship... so we are up to 23 employees just in the manufatureing side of my widget business.

Along comes a computer and machine that can assemble all 20 parts without the need of the humans....

Now being the good boss that I am I want to retain my employees but, they have to be qualified to operate and maintain my new computerized assembly line.

Some will be retained and some will be lost.... those that are retained and trained will in all likelyhood be also recieving pay increases.... as knowlege increases so does the worth of the employee.

So now I have 4 or 5 "technitions" instead of 20 laborer's making more than minimum wage and I'm able to pump out 10 times the widgets I could before and now have to higher more shipping clearks to keep up with the higher demand.

Now by increasing the companies bottom line I'm able to expand into the Whatsits market and build a new plant and hire more technitions... to make the new Whatsits.

And it goes on and on....

Now apply that to karaoke and music.... and you get the same affect in the long run.
 
but for that one PITA turd that has to have the song RIGHT NOW with toqer's solution it's available... heck even without that PITA a kj can easily supliment his own collection legally on the spot and make people happy..... and isn't that the goal anyway?


Of course that's the point, and if I hosted with my PC I would use it as fast as you. I want to keep the PITA as happy ( or happier ) as the next guy. I WOULD use the system, but just because I would doesn't mean it's any better for the economy.
 
Well gee isn't that what they are in business for is to make money or have employees sucking from their bottom line...

1) Sure some employee's are gonna either have to get more tech savy or lose their jobs that's just a part of doing business... as processes change, for good or worse, people have to change as well. Sure that press operator might lose his job and sure that shipping clerk might too.... I highly doubt in the big scheme of things a handfull of "blue color labor" might be lost... believe me McDonalds is always hireing... as far as losing their nickel in the economy it's a very microscoping drop in the economic bucket.

2) For every job lost due to advances in technology a new one is opened by technology.... lets face it as technology advances so does the necesity for individuals with higher education to not only program but also repair and maintain the systems involved in the process....


3) Losing a handfull of minimum wage jobs isn't going to make or break the economy and for every lost job one or two are created for folks with a higher tech knowlege and usually for more money.


1) Not just blue collar, though the volume there HAS caused a huge downturn in the economy. Blue collars have to buy food, housing, clothes, and are able to buy whatever luxuries they can afford. Back in '98, 180,000 blue collars were laid off. Beat hell out of the state economy. There were also a record number of bankruptcies, something like 38,000. That means others didn't get THEIR money, and downsized as well.
Besides blue collar, let's not forget highly paid marketing execs, the distribution matrix, the raw goods suppliers, etc.. LOTTA money going away....


2) Repair and maintainance of new technologies? a) There hasn't been any innovative NEW technology ( which WOULD stimulate the economy) since the early 90's and cell phones. Only new uses found for old technology.

In the last century we came up with economic railways, TV, the transistor, airplanes, JET airplanes, Space technology, computers (analogue), digital technology, the cell phone, etc....All within decades of each other. the 90's was the last. Our hybrid cars are leftover Japese technology, which we get as they improve. WE no longer innovate. B) Maintainance? As far as hard technology goes, what we have today is so cheaply made that it's hardly worth fixing. Either that or it has so few but highly expensive parts ( like a plasma TV) that by the time you buy a replacement it costs more to repair than it does to get a new one. If you are talking about software maintainance, the glut of computer qualified people from teens (or younger) and up make that profession the new "blue collar" job. The pay for those types of positions has already plummeted.

This means that the 4-5 "technicians" don't add to the economy what the 20 did, though more profits end up in the prez's pocket. Also, no is MAKING any widgets in the US. THAT'S done overseas. We just store and tranfer information. That is the only thing we still do better than other places- simply because they don't bother to upgrade. It's cheaper to have us do it . We are to the information business what Korea, Mexico, Guam, Portugal, China, etc.. is to our manufacturing. The cheap market...
 
1) Not just blue collar, though the volume there HAS caused a huge downturn in the economy. Blue collars have to buy food, housing, clothes, and are able to buy whatever luxuries they can afford. Back in '98, 180,000 blue collars were laid off. Beat hell out of the state economy. There were also a record number of bankruptcies, something like 38,000. That means others didn't get THEIR money, and downsized as well.
Besides blue collar, let's not forget highly paid marketing execs, the distribution matrix, the raw goods suppliers, etc.. LOTTA money going away....


2) Repair and maintainance of new technologies? a) There hasn't been any innovative NEW technology ( which WOULD stimulate the economy) since the early 90's and cell phones. Only new uses found for old technology.

In the last century we came up with economic railways, TV, the transistor, airplanes, JET airplanes, Space technology, computers (analogue), digital technology, the cell phone, etc....All within decades of each other. the 90's was the last. Our hybrid cars are leftover Japese technology, which we get as they improve. WE no longer innovate. B) Maintainance? As far as hard technology goes, what we have today is so cheaply made that it's hardly worth fixing. Either that or it has so few but highly expensive parts ( like a plasma TV) that by the time you buy a replacement it costs more to repair than it does to get a new one. If you are talking about software maintainance, the glut of computer qualified people from teens (or younger) and up make that profession the new "blue collar" job. The pay for those types of positions has already plummeted.

So what your saying basically in a nut shell is that it is up to big corporations to keep the employees not willing to advance their educations in jobs that are no longer needed all for the sake of keeping them in the economic stream.

That'a bogus and you know it. Big corporations have no resposibility to the welfare of their workers especially the ones that fall behind on the new technologies.... this is neither fair or unfair... it's just a fact of business.

As for the so called "blue collar" worker there will always be some sort of mindless job available in other industries as well as McDonalds. If they want the higher paying tech jobs then they need to get educated... in otherwords do or don't it's up to them not big corporations.