Large installation, LCD TV vs. Projector

To many ads? Support ODJT and see no ads!

jtnichol

KCDJ
Oct 25, 2006
4,963
208
50
Leavenworth KS
www.jfproductions.biz
Hello all!

Love the forum.

I'm in the middle of a debate in my fairly large school district.
Should we go with LCD TV's 42" or Projectors?

I'm not talking about brands or prices of components.
I'm talking about long term.
If our school district is going to purchase 100 of something, I think we really need to examine the long term effects.

I'm on the side of LCD TV's simply for the longevity.
Projector people are on the side of bigger is better.....

What do you think?
In particular, what have you seen schools in your area do?

Thanks for any help you may have.

Pros and Cons please!~

I have a bunch of them in my head, but I'm looking for some 3rd party answers here.
 
though LCD's are now thin line a Projection system can disappear as simply as putting away the screen.
 
Our University has gone all Projectors, look at what the big boys are doing as a hint :)

Projectors give you a larger image, are more compact, less apt to be stolen if properly installed with security features.

Only disadvantage is institutions wish to spend money only on low costing projectors with low brightness. 4,000 lumen's would be bare minimum for a room with no windows and would be engulfed in blackness, in fact, our communication's department at our university purchased a Sanyo 6,000 Lumen projector which needs to have lights turned out to still be effective.
 
All good points.

The district is interested in $600 Epson projectors. 2200 lumen.

I'm interested in 42" LCD. Little more than twice the cost.

Also, much data indicates leaving the lights on for instruction. At least some of the rooms will at minimum shut half the lights off and block outside light to combat picture issues....

No need to do that with LCD.....

Thanks to all who are responding to this.....
 
I emailed a tech at a school district in MO. Here's what they put into a forum....

Flat Panel verses Projector Thead

Most of the Large Flat Panel LCD, or Plasma TV’s come with a VGA port...They’re just a big monitor with TV tuner...But you have to make sure it has the VGA port before you buy...The large Flat Panel TV’s have come down a lot in price this past year...So, I decided to try some...This is the first year and the teachers that have them really like them, and I’m really impressed too...I want one for home... :)
Even though they are a little smaller than a Smartboard they are a lot more usable for us, the way we use smartboards...And the picture is amazing compared to the projectors screen, you don’t have to turn
the lights off...
The TV’s I bought have two AV connections (like for a VCR or DVD), one Super Video, VGA, Cable, and Air connectors...So, I have a VCR and a DVD and the cable, and Air, and the teachers computer hooked
up...All the teacher has to do is change modes on the TV and poof...You still have all the cabling expense as you would with a projector... BUT, you don’t have that $400.00 lamp replacement fee to come up
with every other year...That was my reason for the TV instead of the Smartboard...These TV’s are about three inches thick and hang on the wall...I saw some 50” Plasma Flat Panels in Wal-Mart a while
back for around $1000.00...I gave $1300.00 for the 42” LCD’s I got this summer...The good thing about them are they’re suppose to last 50,000 hours compared to 1500 hours a projector lamp is suppose to
last...I’ve never got more than 500 hours out of any lamp I have replace so far...And a 30 day warranty!!! If you want to use them like a smartboard you can buy an overlay which would alow it to be interactive like a smartboard...I think that is pretty expensive though...My main reason for trying them was because of these Over Priced lamps...I’m sure there are teachers that would rather have a smartboard...
These are working out great for us...
Hope this helps,
Bill



Terry,
I installed five Large LCD flat panel TV’s this summer and they are working out great for how we use them...But Like Nancy says the text may not be quite as ledgable on the TV as they are on the
Smartboard...Lamp expense was our reason for trying the TV’s...But, If a classroom requires stand-up presentations the way the Smartboard was designed to be used—then I’d get a smartboard and
projector...Most of our Smartboards weren’t being used in a presentation like fashion...so I tried the TV’s and they are working out great for us...No more $350.00 - $400.00 every few years for those rooms with LCD TV’s...I think projector lamps are WAY over priced...If they were reasonably priced at $25.00 or even $100.00 then it wouldn’t such a big deal for us...Or if they would just last forever!!! :) I know, I know...Nothing last forever...
Bill
John,

We were going to purchase four 50” TV’s this summer but couldn’t get the ones that we had planned on...so I got five 42” Viewsonic’s instead of the four others...The price has come down since I purchased these this summer...The Sanyo’s at Wal-Mart look pretty good IF they have a VGA port on them...I think we gave around $1200.00 but I think you can get them for just under $1000.00 now...There is also a cabling cost too...That will vary with the distance you need...
Bill


They are Viewsonic, Model 4251w...These are 42” LCD’s we purchased from CDWG...I was gonna get the 50” but didn’t have enough money to buy five so I opted to get a little smaller screen...One of our teachers bought a Polaroid LCD TV from Wal-Mart...It’s okay but not quite as good as the Viewsonics picture
quality...The main thing is to make sure the LCD TV has a VGA port on it...The price has come down some since we bought these...
Bill

Chris,
I’ve been putting in large flat panel LCD TV’s in classrooms that don’t use the smartboard features...This “for me” kills about five birds with one stone...I hook the Cable, Antenna, DVD, VCR, Computers audio and video up and all the teacher has to do is change the TV’s Mode with the remote...Also the TV’s have a 50,000 hour “estimated” use (MTBF) compared to 1500 hours “estimated” time with the
projectors...The teachers that have them love them and the ones that don’t have them want them...At
our district I have never got over 500 hours use out of any projectors lamp...This is the first year so we’ll see how the flat panel LCD TV’s work out...The picture quality on the TV’s is great...For the price of two lamps I can almost buy a Large flat panel TV...So far it’s working great for us...
Bill

Wayne,
Yes, we bought five 42” Viewsonic LCD TV’s...I am really impressed with the picture quality and the ease of use...The none technical teacher can even use them, and I like that...Even though they are smaller than the smart board it is much more viewable...I think it was the right decision for our district because most of our users don’t use half the features the smart boards were designed for...Everyone wants one now...The price has come down even since we’ve bought ours...Here are a few pro’s:
1. Bulit in Stereo Speakers
2. Extra bright and clear, image is viewable from the side of the screen
3. No three or four hundred dollar Lamp the purchase every other year
4. Can hook up Cable, Antenna, DVD, VCR, and a computer and just switch to the input you want to use

Come on down and look any time...
Bill

Sharon,
http://www.focusedtechnology.com/lambyman.html
Here’s a good place to check all the manufacturer’s lamp prices at a glance...This site makes it a lot easier to see the lamp price when considering a projector...
If you are referring to DLP and LCD TV’s, the LCD and Plasma’s are flat panel (three to six inches thick) that can be mounted on the wall and most have a VGA connector, and the DLP is a projection TV that are larger and can’t be mounted to the wall and I think they have a projection lamp...We are purchasing five LCD TV’s soon instead of Smartboard and Projectors...
Bill
Since I’m not a teacher I guess I only see the cost...You, being a teacher that uses it see it’s value... Gives me a different outlook on it...Thanks for your input...
Bill

On 16 May 2007 at 13:12, Royce Cozine wrote:
As a high school math teacher (and network admin), I would never want to give up my Smart Board. If a school doesn’t see the value in it, it might be because they are not using all of its capabilities. I’m sure some teachers could survive fine without the Smart Board capabilities, but in math at least, it is my most important technology in my classroom. What can I do now compared to what I could do six or seven years ago (pre-Smart Board) is such a phenomenal difference. I would also say that if it was a writing pad instead of a Smart Board, it would definitely limit my capabilities also. I still believe Smart Board is the best of all the interactive boards, but that might just be what I am used to. Anyway, I wanted to add my opinion since there is nothing worse than purchasing something that later you find is not exactly what you wanted.
Royce Cozine
Jefferson C-123 Schools


I’m put out with the prices of projector Lamps costing three, four, or even $500.00...The Lamps are suppose to last around 1500 hours, but the most I have got out of a lamp is 490 hours...Mitsubishi seems to have the cheapest priced lamps...The short lamp life could be the way we use or treat the projectors...We had
three lamps burn out a couple of weeks ago...So I searched around and found bargain prices but it still cost $884.00 to replace those lamps...I don’t know—I think the lamps are WAY over priced...So, this is what we are thinking about doing...Unless the classroom requires a presenter in front of the class and actually need a smartboard for it’s features (most of our teachers don’t) we are going to buy either Flat Panel LCD, or PLASMA TV’s (Plasmas get burn-in easily, LCD’s don’t) that have a VGA connector on them...The screen life on these are meant to last 40,000, to 50,000 hours of use...That’s like 25 years of normal use...LCD’s are still a little pricey yet but the Plasma TV’s have come down a lot in the past six months...Wal-Mart has the LCD 42” TV’s for $995.00 then all you need is the wall mount for it and cables to view the TV with either a antenna/cable connection, DVD/VHS player or PC...I just can’t justify the three and four hundred dollar projector lamp prices anymore, it’s ridiculous...So, finally my question is:

Is anyone else doing this or considering it???I have done some research but there are lots of options...These TV’s are about three inches thick and can be mounted on the wall with a $100.00 mount, then the cost of cabling for about another $100.00...Projectors and smartboards are priced around $2500.00 for the lower end projector then there’s the pricey lamp problem in a few years...I want to know what everyone else
is doing, or even thinking...I just can’t justify the lamp prices...This $995.00 TV will take the place of the other TV in the room, the smartboard, then you can buy a wireless mouse if you need one...if it were my money I sure wouldn’t spend it this way, so I feel really guilty about spending district money on over priced lamps...Give me your thoughts...Someone please correct me if I’m wrong...

Feedback please... :)
Thanks,
Bill
 
JT, I haven't said anything cause I thought you were so set on TV's, but I think projectors are the way to go. In a classroom full of students SIZE MATTERS. I'd take a 6 X 6 foot screen over resolution any day, so that kid in the back that refuses to wear their glasses doesn't have an excuse to miss the notes! The projector in my room (which I leave on all night sometimes by accident) is still on bulb #1 2 years in. Every room in my district has a ceiling mounted projector, two Bose ceiling speakers, small amp/changer...I use it everyday for sure (of course I've brought in my own surround system with an extra sub under my desk...the teacher next door LOVES me).

I know you'll ultimately be bound by the districts decision...either way make sure your the man doing the installs.

Nardini
 
Lotta people are skipping a biggie, but with the same result-viewing angle. LCDs can be a problem outside of a certain angle. For large audiences you want a projector- No viewing problems from any angle...
 
Kris - your installation sounds just like what we had in every classroom on the Wake Forest campus in 2004. The majority of classes had Sharp LCD projectors, with some scattered Epson or N.E.C.'s Every classroom is now outfitted with a multi-media system that incorporates an AMX touch screen system that is programmed for each individual rooms needs. Granted, the lamp cost is rather steep for each unit at approximately $295 and up, but your point about the student in the back of the classroom not being able to miss taking notes, is spot on.

Jeremiah - If you would like, I can put you in touch with the Sharp sales rep. on the east coast. He's a personal friend. He made Wake a great deal on the projectors.

If you are instead interested in going with either whiteboards or flat screens, my sales rep here in Winston that I deal with and Wake deals with on electronics and other Audio/Visual needs can probably beat just about any other deal.

She is the head sales person for One Source Building Technologies/Long Communications.

Just my thoughts..........
 
JT, I haven't said anything cause I thought you were so set on TV's, but I think projectors are the way to go. In a classroom full of students SIZE MATTERS. I'd take a 6 X 6 foot screen over resolution any day, so that kid in the back that refuses to wear their glasses doesn't have an excuse to miss the notes! The projector in my room (which I leave on all night sometimes by accident) is still on bulb #1 2 years in. Every room in my district has a ceiling mounted projector, two Bose ceiling speakers, small amp/changer...I use it everyday for sure (of course I've brought in my own surround system with an extra sub under my desk...the teacher next door LOVES me).

I know you'll ultimately be bound by the districts decision...either way make sure your the man doing the installs.

Nardini

Don't you think 42" is big enough?
I've got a band director in a 30' by 50' room and kids have no trouble reading what he's doing online; at any angle.

If Johnny has a big issue with reading from the back of the room, then he needs to sit next to the ugliest girl you can find in the front.....lol.....

Try it sometime, run to the TV section at any store and step back about 50'. Text is very presentable even at that distance. Most of the classrooms I'm talking about are 20 X 25.

Do you have to shut off your lights?

As far as me doing the installs....I don't think I will be. If I'm gonna do the install for projectors, I don't want to mess with routing cables through the ceiling, changing bulbs, or cleaning filters. That waste of time and money can be up to them....I know already I'm not the vendor for them anyway.

As for flat screens. I don't think they'll go through me for that either. Especially if I persuade the big bosses to go my route. I don't make money on the TV's anyway....I just want what best for the kids and taxpayers.....Projectors are gonna be a real drain on the district I'm afraid. We just won't have the budget to keep up with the bulbs, I have a feeling.

My ultimate dream is that they put projectors in where they seem to make the most sense if they do go that route.

Time will tell.....
 
I hear you about size, it's just nice to throw a video up there and have it fill the whole wall. I do have to turn out the lights to see it clearly.

I hear you about doing what's best for the kids...too often that is the last consideration instead of the first.

Keep doing what you're doing!
 
Correction....rooms are 25 X 35...

Yes knardini, whats best for kids, because whats best for kids eventually becomes best for adults.

I'm thinking long term here.
The TV's I think will exceed expectations while keeping long term money in the district for other goods/services.

Spend the money now, so you don't have to later....

Dude, what you doin'?

I should call when the kids get to bed.....
 
as a teachers aide sports/ games director, bus driver as well as coach in several types of school sports I didnt notice one of them being Ugly, or if they were black or white. I treated each of them equally the same with strict care but Totally fair.
 
I don't know man, you should see this one girl I have in 3rd hour......wait a minute, she might be a boy come to think about it.....no she's a girl with a very masculine build - sort of looks like that mug shot of Nick Nolte.

Just kidding, I have 3rd hour plan. You gotta treat them all like thier your own. In a lot of cases I'm the only positive adult role model in thier lives.

Now that's a scary thought!
 
I attempted to give them 20-40 minutes per day of positivity each and every one of them and especially those who werent in the status quo. Though I recognized that I treated them no different than any of the others.
 
as a teachers aide sports/ games director, bus driver as well as coach in several types of school sports I didnt notice one of them being Ugly, or if they were black or white. I treated each of them equally the same with strict care but Totally fair.

I can look at a group of kids long enough.
Watch their interaction
and figure out which ones THEY think are inferior for one reason or another.
Its pretty easy to convince "johnny" in the back to do what you want him to do if you figure out a way to pair him off with the one person in class who can push his "yes sir" button....without doing it in a way that will hurt another person....
 
not if Johnny calls this person ugly what if this so called ugly girl has a secret crush on Johnny? Now if I can get a girl to make Johnny look foolish cause he shows off while doing a layup drill I will do it and have had the girls beat boys in basketball and football in elementary level because of their endless attempts to show off lol.