I never said CR, I said user experience - and if you base it off user experience, Tacoma is the best, hands down. Tacoma also outsells them all. It is the number 1 compact truck. Tacoma had a redesign recently, so they're haven't gotten to the top of their game yet .. but they'll get there. If you watch the sales, you'll never see a Tacoma at 0% interest - because they know they'll sell. The only competition the Tacoma really has is the Chevy Colorado Z series and while Chevy has performed miracles with this truck, it's no Tacoma.
*Shoppers who plan to venture far off the beaten path can look to the specially equipped off-road-performance models offered by the Chevrolet Colorado (the ZR2 and new ZR2 Bison) and Toyota Tacoma (the TRD Off-Road and TRO Pro).*
If it's so bad, I wonder why it and the Colorado are the only recommendations.
*The Tacoma is one of the most capable pickup trucks on the road regardless of size. For truck shoppers wanting to go as far off the beaten path as possible, the Tacoma will be a great choice. It'll also tow up to 6,800 pounds, and it enjoys a great reputation for high resale value and aftermarket parts support.*
Hmmm .. one of the most capable .. but it's at the bottom of the list? Does that even make sense?
While Tundra is not the king of the full size market (and Toyota has no intent on being #1 of that market), they don't spend alot of time in the shop and the owners love their trucks. They just work.